Fetch Pet Insurance, Pet Insurance

Love Longer

Turning monthly savings into more happier and healthier years together

The brief

Fetch is a premium pet insurer in a category where every brand sells on coverage statistics, so price ends up deciding. The job was to give people another reason to choose it.

The reframe

Most people buy pet insurance as protection against a bad day. Fetch could sell it as a long-term investment in more healthy years with your pet, and its coverage already backed that up.

My role

Senior Strategist, Prosek Partners

I repositioned Fetch from a purchase people put up with to an investment in their pet’s long life. From there we built the Love Longer platform and its messaging system.

Figures

  • $500KRaised at Fetch’s first NYC gala, which the campaign supported
Fetch billboard reading 'For every age, every stage, every phase. Love longer.' with a woman hugging her dog

Where the category stood

Customer-focusedSelf-focused
Love Longer
Every competitor
Immediate, transactional valueLong-term value
We mapped every major competitor on two axes. All of them sat in the bottom-left quadrant, which left the top-right open for Fetch.

The full case

Problem
Pet insurance is sold with statistics: up to 90% coverage, most comprehensive, best-in-class reimbursement. In a category dominated by impersonal facts, meaning had disappeared. Fetch, a premium-priced, best-in-class product, was stuck competing on the same transactional ground as everyone else. When every brand sounds the same, price becomes the only differentiator, and customers churn.
Insight
The category sells protection against what might go wrong tomorrow. But Fetch’s customers treat their pets as family, and the most powerful thing Fetch sells is time. So I redefined insurance from a reactive safety net to an investment in more years together. Nobody owned the longevity story, even though Fetch’s coverage was already built for it.
Framework
A competitive audit mapped every major player onto a simple 2×2: self-focused vs. customer-focused, and immediate transactional value vs. long-term value. They all clustered in the same quadrant. The open space was customer-focused and long-term, the only place a premium brand could credibly stand. We tested platform options against four criteria: ladder to brand purpose, incorporate Everyday Matters, tie the business units together, and break category convention.
Decision
We started with a full audit of Fetch’s materials plus independent research, then mapped competitor messaging to find the gaps, clichés, and white space. I built the strategic frame from the client’s own DNA and ran platform options through the four criteria. That led to one platform, Love Longer, which moves the story from coverage to longevity and turns a functional truth into an emotional commitment.
Execution
The platform became a full messaging system: a framework across insurance, wellness, and partnerships, with every reason to believe rewritten from functional language into longevity language. The campaign used honest, human creative. Real pets and owners, natural light, and quiet markers like “Insured since 2018” signal longevity without shouting, with headlines like “Coverage that keeps the years coming.” No fear, no theatrics.
Fetch campaign executions: a bus shelter ad, social posts and mobile web pages (open full size in a new tab)
One system across out of home, messaging and web
Fetch Love Longer creative across social, desktop web, billboards and print posters (open full size in a new tab)
Love Longer across social, web, out of home and print